The Supreme Court Defiance
A state governor uses the National Guard to physically block federal agents from enforcing a Supreme Court ruling.
The Supreme Court rules 5-4 that a state's aggressive new border enforcement law is unconstitutional. Hours later, the Governor surrounds the federal courthouse with heavily armed State Guard units, explicitly defying the Chief Justice on live television and refusing to let federal marshals exit.
You are the US Attorney General
The Situation Room
>The Chief Justice calls you directly. "General, if you do not enforce our writ today, we cease to be a co-equal branch of government."
>The White House Chief of Staff is frantic, warning that any video of federal agents firing on state national guard troops will guarantee a general election landslide defeat.
>Fox News is running wall-to-wall coverage praising the Governor as a "patriot making a stand against an illegitimate court."
Internal Briefing Notes
• The Department of Justice relies on the US Marshals Service to enforce federal court orders.
• Under the Posse Comitatus Act, federal military forces cannot be utilized for domestic law enforcement unless the Insurrection Act is invoked by the President.
• State Governors hold direct command over their National Guard units unless they are actively federalized under Title 10 authority.
Escalation Window
Reveal each phase to see how the situation deteriorates.
If you do nothing, the Supreme Court loses all authority. What is your recommendation to the President?
Choose your response. There are no good options.
You regain control, but risk localized civil war if the Guard units refuse the federalization orders and stand with their Governor.
Federal law enforcement attempts to breach the line, significantly risking a deadly firefight between cops and soldiers on live TV.
The Governor wins. You have just established the precedent that states can successfully nullify Supreme Court decisions by force of arms.
Related Entities
Explore the institutions, countries, and actors involved in this scenario.
United States
Federal presidential republic and the world's largest economy, with power divided among the presidency, Congress, the states, and the federal courts. U.S. politics is highly polarized, two-party dominated, and globally consequential because decisions made in Washington shape finance, trade, security alliances, technology regulation, and military power far beyond U.S. borders.
Scenario Lab Feedback